Document Type: Original Article


1 Department of Ocean and Mechanical Engineering, Florida Atlantic University, 777 Glades Road Boca Raton, FL 33431, USA.

2 Department of Renewable Energies, Faculty of New Sciences and Technologies, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.



Finding a superior evaluation for an irreversible actual heat engine (irreversible Carnot heat engine) can be mentioned as the substantial purpose of this study. To obtain this purpose, the considered criteria are Ecological Coefficient of Performance (ECOP), exergetic performance coefficient thermo-economic, ecological-based thermo-economic, and ecologico-economical functions. These criteria are optimized by implementing NSGA II and thermodynamic analysis. Irreversibilities of the system is considered for the study assessment, consequently, two states are specified in the optimization procedure. The findings associated with every scheme are assessed independently. In the first scenario, maximizing the power output, First law efficiency of the system, and dimensionless ecological-based thermo-economic function ( ) is set as the target. In the second scenario, the three objective functions such as power output ( ), efficiency ( ) and dimensionless ecologico-economical ( ) are simultaneously maximized. To be clear, the coupled of multi-objective evolutionary approaches (MOEAs) and non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm (NSGA-II) approach are presented. The comparison of three prominent approaches such as: LINAMP, TOPSIS, and FUZZY performs in decision making. Ultimately, error analyses of results based on Maximum Absolute Percentage Error are carried out. According to the results, in the first scenario, the appropriate results were the result of the decisions made by TOPSIS and LINAMP, with a deviation index equal to 0.322 from the ideal ratio of this scenario. In the second scenario, the best decision-making results were achieved by the TOPSIS method, with a deviation index equal to 0.104 from the ideal state for this scenario.


[1] Ahmadi MH, Nazari MA, Sadeghzadeh M, Pourfayaz F, Ghazvini M, Ming T, et al. Thermodynamic and economic analysis of performance evaluation of all the thermal power plants: A review. Energy Sci Eng 2019; 7:30–65.

[2] Ahmadi MH, Banihashem SA, Ghazvini M, Sadeghzadeh M. Thermo-economic and exergy assessment and optimization of performance of a hydrogen production system by using geothermal energy. Energy Environ 2018; 29:1373–92.

[3] Ahmadi MH, Mohammadi O, Sadeghzadeh M, Pourfayaz F, Kumar R, Lorenzini G. Exergy and Economic Analysis of Solar Chimney in Iran Climate: Tehran, Semnan, and Bandar Abbas. Math Model Eng Probl 2020; 7:55–67.

[4] Ahmadi M, Sadaghiani M, Pourfayaz F, Ghazvini M, Mahian O, Mehrpooya M, et al. Energy and Exergy Analyses of a Solid Oxide Fuel Cell-Gas Turbine-Organic Rankine Cycle Power Plant with Liquefied Natural Gas as Heat Sink. Entropy 2018; 20:484.

[5] Mohammadi A, Ahmadi MH, Bidi M, Ghazvini M, Ming T. Exergy and economic analyses of replacing feedwater heaters in a Rankine cycle with parabolic trough collectors. Energy Reports 2018; 4:243–51.

[6] Assad MEH. Thermodynamic analysis of an irreversible MHD power plant. Int J Energy Res 2000; 24:865–75.

[7] Zhou S, Chen L, Sun F, Wu C. Cooling Load Density Optimization of an Irreversible Simple Brayton Refrigerator. Open Syst Inf Dyn 2002; 9:325–37.

[8] Nylund C, Assad MEH. Energy Optimization of Heat Engine with Infinite Heat Capacity Reservoirs 2013.

[9] Çengel YA, Boles MA. Thermodynamics: an engineering approach. McGraw-Hill; 2011.


[10] Novikov II. The efficiency of atomic power stations (a review). J Nucl Energy 1958;7:125–8.

[11] Curzon FL, Ahlborn B. Efficiency of a Carnot engine at maximum power output. Am J Phys 1975; 43:22–4.

[12] Ge Y, Chen L, Qin X, Xie Z. Exergy-based ecological performance of an irreversible Otto cycle with temperature-linear-relation variable specific heat of working fluid. Eur Phys J Plus 2017 1325 2017; 132:1–9.

[13] Vaudrey A, Lanzetta F, Feidt M. H. B. Reitlinger and the origins of the Efficiency at Maximum Power formula for Heat Engines. J Non-Equilibrium Thermodyn 2014; 39:199–203.

[14] Wu Z, Chen L, Ge Y, Sun F. Power, efficiency, ecological function and ecological coefficient of performance of an irreversible Dual-Miller cycle (DMC) with nonlinear variable specific heat ratio of working fluid. Eur Phys J Plus 2017 1325 2017; 132:1–17.

[15] Chen L, Ding Z, Zhou J, Wang W, Sun F. Thermodynamic performance optimization for an irreversible vacuum thermionic generator. Eur Phys J Plus 2017 1327 2017; 132:1–12.

[16] Yin Y, Chen L, Wu F. Optimal power and efficiency of quantum Stirling heat engines. Eur Phys J Plus 2017 1321 2017; 132:1–10.

[17] Xia S, Chen L, Sun F. Maximum cycle work output optimization for generalized radiative law Otto cycle engines. Eur Phys J Plus 2016 13111 2016; 131:1–14.

[18] Madadi V, Tavakoli T, Rahimi A. Estimation of heat loss from a cylindrical cavity receiver based on simultaneous energy and exergy analyses. J Non-Equilibrium Thermodyn 2015; 40:49–61.

[19] Angulo-Brown F. An ecological optimization criterion for finite-time heat engines. J Appl Phys 1991; 69:7465–9.

[20] Yan Z. Comment on “an ecological optimization criterion for finite-time heat engines” [J. Appl. Phys. 69, 7465, (1991)]. J Appl Phys 1993; 73:3583.

[21] Açikkalp E. Methods used for evaluation of actual power generating thermal cycles and comparing them. Int J Electr Power Energy Syst 2015; 69:85–9.

[22] Açikkalp E. Exergetic sustainability evaluation of irreversible Carnot refrigerator. Phys A Stat Mech Its Appl 2015; 436:311–20.  

[23] Özel G, Ackkalp E, Savas AF, Yamk H. Novel thermoenvironmental evaluation criteria and comparing them for an actual heat engine. Energy Convers Manag 2015; 106:1118–23.

[24] Özel G, Açlkkalp E, Savaş AF, Yamlk H. Comparative Analysis of Thermoeconomic Evaluation Criteria for an Actual Heat Engine. J Non-Equilibrium Thermodyn 2016; 41:225–35.

[25] J. Chen. The maximum power output and maximum efficiency of an irreversible Carnot heat engine. J Phys D Appl Phys 1994; 27:1144–9.

[26] S Ozkaynak SG and HY. Finite-time thermodynamic analysis of a radiative heat engine with internal irreversibility. J Phys D Appl Phys 1994; 27:1139–43.

[27] C. Cheng and C. Chen. The ecological optimization of an irreversible Carnot heat-engine. J Phys D Appl Phys 1997; 30:1602–9.

[28] Xia D, Chen L, Sun F, Wu C. Universal ecological performance for endo-reversible heat engine cycles. Int J Ambient Energy 2006; 27:15–20.

[29] Chen L, Zhou J, Sun F, Wu C. Ecological optimization for generalized irreversible Carnot engines. Appl Energy 2004; 77:327–38.

[30] Zhu X, Chen L, Sun F, Wu C. Exergy-based ecological optimization for a generalized irreversible Carnot refrigerator. J Energy Inst 2006; 79:42–6.

[31] Ibrahim DM, Klein SA, Mitchell JW. Optimum heat power cycles for specified boundary conditions. J Eng Gas Turbines Power 1991; 113:514–21.

[32] De Vos A. Endoreversible economics. Energy Convers Manag 1997; 38:311–7.

[33] Sahin B, Kodal A. Finite time thermoeconomic optimization for endoreversible refrigerators and heat pumps. Energy Convers Manag 1999; 40:951–60.

[34] Sadatsakkak SA, Ahmadi MH, Ahmadi MA. Thermodynamic and thermo-economic analysis and optimization of an irreversible regenerative closed Brayton cycle. Energy Convers Manag 2015; 94:124–9.

[35] Ahmadi MH, Ahmadi MA, Bayat R, Ashouri M, Feidt M. Thermo-economic optimization of Stirling heat pump by using non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm. Energy Convers Manag 2015; 91:315–22.

[36] Ahmadi MH, Ahmadi MA, Mehrpooya M, Hosseinzade H, Feidt M. Thermodynamic and thermo-economic analysis and optimization of performance of irreversible four-temperature-level absorption refrigeration. Energy Convers Manag 2014; 88:1051–9.

[37] Ahmadi MH, Sayyaadi H, Mohammadi AH, Barranco-Jimenez MA. Thermo-economic multi-objective optimization of solar dish-Stirling engine by implementing evolutionary algorithm. Energy Convers Manag 2013; 73:370–80.

[38] Barranco-Jiménez MA, Sánchez-Salas N. Effect of combined heat transfer on the thermoeconomic performance of an irreversible solar-driven heat engine at maximum ecological conditions. Vol. 59. 2013.

[39] Chen L, Sun F, Wu C. Thermo-economics for endoreversible heat-engines. Appl Energy 2005; 81:388–96.

[40] Chen L, Xiaoqin Z, Sun F, Wu C. Exergy-based ecological optimization for a generalized irreversible Carnot heat-pump. Appl Energy 2007; 84:78–88.

[41] Chen L, Zhang W, Sun F. Power, efficiency, entropy-generation rate and ecological optimization for a class of generalized irreversible universal heat-engine cycles. Appl Energy 2007; 84:512–25.

[42] Ust Y, Sahin B, Sogut OS. Performance analysis and optimization of an irreversible dual-cycle based on an ecological coefficient of performance criterion. Appl Energy 2005;82:23–39.

[43] Ust Y, Sahin B. Performance optimization of irreversible refrigerators based on a new thermo-ecological criterion. Int J Refrig 2007; 30:527–34.

[44] Ust Y, Sahin B, Kodal A, Akcay IH. Ecological coefficient of performance analysis and optimization of an irreversible regenerative-Brayton heat engine. Appl Energy 2006; 83:558–72.

[45] Ust Y, Akkaya A V., Safa A. Analysis of a vapour compression refrigeration system via exergetic performance coefficient criterion. J Energy Inst 2011; 84:66–72.

[46] Akkaya AV, Sahin B, Huseyin Erdem H. An analysis of SOFC/GT CHP system based on exergetic performance criteria. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2008; 33:2566–77.

[47] Mironova VA, Tsirlin AM, Kazakov VA, Berry RS. Finite-time thermodynamics: Exergy and optimization of time-constrained processes. J Appl Phys 1994; 76:629–36.


[48] Andresen B, Rubin MH, Berry RS. Availability for finite-time processes. General theory and a model. J Phys Chem 1983; 87:2704–13.

[49] Blecic I, Cecchini A, Trunfio GA. A decision support tool coupling a causal model and a multi-objective genetic algorithm. Appl Intell 2007; 26:125–37.

[50] Ombuki B, Ross BJ, Hanshar F. Multi-objective genetic algorithms for vehicle routing problem with time windows. Appl Intell 2006; 24:17–30.

[51] Özyer T, Zhang M, Alhajj R. Integrating multi-objective genetic algorithm based clustering and data partitioning for skyline computation. Appl Intell 2011; 35:110–22.

[52] Van Veldhuizen DA, Lamont GB. Multiobjective evolutionary algorithms: analyzing the state-of-the-art. Evol Comput 2000; 8:125–47.

[53] Ahmadi MH, Hosseinzade H, Sayyaadi H, Mohammadi AH, Kimiaghalam F. Application of the multi-objective optimization method for designing a powered Stirling heat engine: Design with maximized power, thermal efficiency and minimized pressure loss. Renew Energy 2013; 60:313–22.

[54] Ahmadi MH, Dehghani S, Mohammadi AH, Feidt M, Barranco-Jimenez MA. Optimal design of a solar driven heat engine based on thermal and thermo-economic criteria. Energy Convers Manag 2013; 75:635–42.

[55] Ahmadi MH, Sayyaadi H, Dehghani S, Hosseinzade H. Designing a solar powered Stirling heat engine based on multiple criteria: Maximized thermal efficiency and power. Energy Convers Manag 2013; 75:282–91.

[56] Ahmadi MH, Ahmadi MA, Mohammadi AH, Mehrpooya M, Feidt M. Thermodynamic optimization of Stirling heat pump based on multiple criteria. Energy Convers Manag 2014; 80:319–28.

[57] Ahmadi MH, Ahmadi MA, Mohammadi AH, Feidt M, Pourkiaei SM. Multi-objective optimization of an irreversible Stirling cryogenic refrigerator cycle. Energy Convers Manag 2014; 82:351–60.

[58] Ahmadi MH, Mohammadi AH, Dehghani S. Evaluation of the maximized power of a regenerative endoreversible Stirling cycle using the thermodynamic analysis. Energy Convers Manag 2013; 76:561–70.